Why was Jesus scourged twice?
Reflecting on the Gospels...

Most Christians believe Jesus was whipped right before he was crucified on the cross. However, looking at the gospels, one can easily determine that Jesus was whipped once before Pilate, who desired to release Jesus, and again right before Jesus was about to be crucified.
Pontius Pilate has interrogated Jesus inside the Praetorium and declared Him innocent. However, the crowd outside demands His execution. Pilate decides to compromise, and in John 19:1-5, we find Pilate ordered a localized punishment - historically known in Roman law as a fustigatio - which was a lighter beating used for minor offenses or to warn a prisoner. Pilate’s legal goal was to humiliate Jesus, satisfy the crowd’s anger, and then release Him.
Hence, we find the Roman soldiers jam Jesus’ head with a crown of thorns, as they were mocking Jesus. They dress Him in a fading purple or scarlet soldier’s robe to mock His status as a “king,” saying “Hail, King of the Jews,” striking Him in the face, and spitting on Him in front of the crowds to appease the crowd’s anger by mocking Jesus. (John 19:2-3, Matt 27:27-30)
After the beating, Pilate brings Jesus out to the Jewish leaders and the crowd; Jesus is bleeding from the first whipping, wearing the thorns and the purple robe. Pilate declares, “I find no basis for a charge against him… Behold the man!” Pilate presented Jesus as a pathetic, broken figure who poses no political threat to Rome.
Pilate thought such beating and humiliation would be sufficient for the crowd to subside their anger. However, it did not, and in fact they became more angry and agitated and yelled, “Crucify him! If you let this man go, you are no friend of Caesar! Away with this man!”
Pilate feared a political riot; he sits on the judge’s bench and officially sentences Jesus to death. As part of the mandatory legal protocol for a Roman crucifixion, Pilate orders the second, maximum-severity scourging (verberatio), which is carried out with a weighted flagrum to push the prisoner to the brink of death intentionally. (Matt 27:26, Mark 15:15)
The question that remains in our minds is: why was Jesus scourged, whipped, and beaten twice? We find the answer to that question in Isaiah 53:5:
But he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed.
The first scourging wounded Jesus; he was wounded for our transgressions. The second scourging bruised Jesus for our iniquities.
We must look deeper into our depraved nature and discover the characteristics of our transgressions and iniquities to properly deal with the issue of Jesus’ scourging and what his broken body and blood have done for our nature.
First, the transgressions. A transgression is a rebellion that causes one to cross a known boundary by acting. It is a wilful defiance of a law or authority. It is as if entering a place with a sign that says “no entry,” in willful defiance of authority. It is an action carried out with intent to defy an unauthorized command, not by mistake or accident.
God told Adam not to eat of this tree. However, Adam deliberately took the fruit of the tree of knowledge, defied God’s command, and ate it. It is this deliberate act that has broken the specific established boundary that has caused everyone born from Adam to be a transgressor against God.
Even a young child, when told not to do something, almost always does what they were told not to do. It is in our very nature to defy authorities and disobey. The absolute authority of God was challenged by a creation that bore His image, and by such deliberate action, the image of God in man was distorted. With the ability to create, mankind used their abilities to build things that are contrary to God’s desires and created something ungodly. Mankind will continue to stray away from God with its god-like abilities, but this needs amending—a turning point for mankind to return to God.
To return to God, mankind must reestablish its former glory. For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. (Romans 3:23). God glorified Jesus upon the cross.
Second, the iniquities. Iniquities go deeper than a single rebellious act. It refers to a lifestyle of premeditated sin, systemic corruption, or an inner spiritual bending. The Hebrew word implies being twisted or bent out of shape. Sin becomes a habit, corrupting a person’s conscience and distorting their sense of right and wrong.
We find King David committing adultery with Bathsheba and then plotting the murder of her husband to cover it up is an example of iniquity. It was calculated, premeditated, and grew out of a corrupted heart.
All offspring of Adam are not only capable of transgressing God, but all of their hearts are full of iniquities. You do not need to teach a child to lie, but the child will not only lie, but they will also learn to lie better as they grow in knowledge and experience.
Our fallen nature causes us to manufacture new transgressions in creative ways continually. Our heart is twisted and corrupted to a point where good intentions are received as bad while bad intentions are received as good. We do not know how to resolve the iniquity in the heart.
We can cover up our corrupt nature with religion, morals, and other things. Still, we all know our heart is depraved beyond repair, and unless we address the core issue of a fallen heart, it will remain in a continual state of iniquity; our flesh will quarrel against the Holy Spirit, and we will never be under the glory of God.
Now, we look at Isaiah 53:5 to see what the remedies are for transgressions and for iniquities.
But he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed.
The first scourging of Jesus under Pilate to satisfy the crowd’s anger, where Jesus was crowned with thorns and then beaten, were the wounds that paid for our transgressions. Jesus was unjustly beaten, spitted upon, and humiliated to satisfy the crowd’s jeering and wrong anger towards Jesus. Jesus was crowned with thorns and given a purple robe to wear over his wounds, and the soldiers gave him a reed to hold as if it were a royal scepter.
The crowd looked at the weak, humiliated, and beaten Jesus but was not satisfied. The same look the crowd gave Jesus is the look the Father gives us when we stand in His court. Our fallen nature is full of transgressions, and even one transgression is sufficient to sentence all of us to death. It is we who are ashamed and humiliated in front of the world, as Adam and Eve were naked and made skirts out of leaves to cover their shame. The crowd was the witness to the fallen natured mankind’s destiny of humiliation, shame, and utter despair; both physically and spiritually.
Jesus’ first beating was for the known transgressions that we made against God in defiance of His perfect will. Jesus paid the price for the known defiant transgressions that mankind has made against God, and because of it, Jesus was mocked as the “king of the Jews!” while being beaten with the first stripes. When he was crowned with thorns, the jamming caused his blood vessels around his crown to burst from the piercing of the thorns, and his entire body was covered in the blood from head to toe. The curse of the fallen was placed upon Jesus’ head via the thorns, as the thorns represent all curses mankind is under after Adam’s sin.
Under the curse, everyone has fallen short ofof God's glory and can only commit transgressions. Fallen mankind cannot but transgress against God in everything they do. It was willful disobedience along with defiance of God's rule. That mankind wants to be its own god. There is no place for God to be in our hearts, as our hearts are full of willful disobedience. The first scourging of Jesus was to satisfy the outward actions of our transgressed hearts. Our actions have consequences, and they make us drift further from God.
Jesus paid the price to bridge the gap of disobedience with his flesh and blood, under shame. We are one step closer to God as we partake in Jesus’ first scourging as our glorified King.
The second scourging of Jesus was severe, done to break Jesus and ultimately to kill him. After Pilate gave Jesus over to be crucified to satisfy the crowd’s anger, Jesus was beaten with severe scourging. He was whipped 40 times, with the intent to break him so that he could die on the cross. Jesus was beaten previously, although it was weaker than the second beating; his first beating caused Jesus to bleed and be tired beyond measure. It explains why Jesus collapsed on the way to Golgotha and died only after six hours on the cross. Most prisoners to be crucified get whipped once, 40 stripes. However, Jesus was beaten before and then was scourged 40 times again, completely breaking him.
Jesus was completely bloodied, and he was unrecognizable as a person after the second beating. Why was he beaten the second time? Isaiah 53:5 says:
But he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed.
He was bruised for our iniquities. In other translations, it says he became blue for our iniquities. He was pulverized by the scourging; his body was bleeding inside, and it caused his inside to bruise blue. Why was his inside beaten mercilessly? It was to deal with the heart of fallen mankind.
Jesus was internally bruised, and his body ballooned due to the bruise. He was unrecognizable as a person, but one almost slaughtered to death, drenched in his own blood. His insides were inflamed beyond repair, and all of his organs began to fail due to excessive bleeding. His heart was about to burst to compensate for the blood loss and the pain of being struck in the same area he had previously beaten. His insides were coming out, and every nerve was lit up as if it had been salted. He was going through a shock that would kill a person. He fell down while carrying the cross because his body cramped up with spasms and was under severe shock and distress.
Jesus was bruised for our iniquities, meaning that he was scourged a second time, causing the first wounds not to heal and causing second trauma to the same area that was exposed from the first beating. Iniquities are conditions of the fallen heart. It needs the heart exposed and replaced to fully renew it. It is insufficient to deal with it without the inside coming out through extreme beating. The extreme beating was taken by Jesus in the most grotesque manner.
By Jesus’ broken flesh and internal bleeding, our iniquities against God were remedied. It was we who needed to be beaten mercilessly, but by Jesus taking it upon him, we have received the gift of peace between God and us.
Through Jesus’ stripes, we are healed means our depraved, unrestorable heart of iniquities was replaced with Jesus’ heart; hence, we have peace with God. When God looks at us, He does not look at our depraved heart. He looks at Jesus' heart. Jesus’ heart was transplanted to ours through his two-time scourging. “ We are healed" means our relationship with God has been restored, and we can access God at any time through Jesus’ broken flesh and blood.
We do not stop sinning with our own abilities. Jesus has dealt with the core issue of the depraved heart that continually commits iniquities. Rely on Jesus and focus on what He did for us when He was scourged twice: the first scourging was for humiliation because of our transgressions, and the second scourging was for the restoration of our depraved iniquities in our hearts.
We do not try not to sin; rather, we strive to be close with Jesus by daily eating His flesh and blood. Our nature changes naturally, not by our actions or discipline. When we realize this, we can truly rest in Jesus, and our fight is not against our own transgressions or iniquities; Jesus has already dealt with them, but we strive to live a life in obedience to the Holy Spirit.











